The Right Control for the Right Job: Fail-Safe Electric's Expertise in Both PLC and Non-PLC Automation
- Ryan Patrick Murray
- 2 days ago
- 3 min read

In the realm of electrical control and automation, there's a diverse landscape of technologies available. At one end, you have sophisticated PLC (Programmable Logic Controller) systems capable of managing incredibly complex processes, handling vast amounts of data, and offering immense flexibility. At the other, you have robust, dedicated non-PLC controls – systems built on proven relay logic, timers, and discrete components – offering straightforward reliability for specific, often critical, tasks.
So, which approach is "better"? The truth is, neither is inherently superior in all situations. The "best" control solution is the one that is right for the specific job at hand. At Fail-Safe Electric in Tacoma, Washington, we pride ourselves on not being tied to a single technology. Instead, we leverage our deep expertise across both PLC-based automation and dedicated non-PLC controls to provide our clients with the most effective, reliable, and cost-efficient solution tailored precisely to their needs.
Understanding the Landscape: PLC vs. Non-PLC Controls
PLC-Based Automation: PLCs are the powerhouses for complex automation. They are ideal when you need:
Sophisticated Logic & Sequencing: Managing multiple interdependent operations, intricate process control (like in our Automated Sewage Control Systems with intelligent pump management or Automated Fish Screening Controllers with adaptive cleaning cycles).
Data Logging & Communication: Gathering performance data, historical trending, remote monitoring/control (often desired for SCADA integration), and generating compliance reports.
Flexibility & Scalability: The ability to modify control logic through programming if processes change or expand.
Advanced Diagnostics: Pinpointing issues within complex systems (e.g., our UL Listed Gantry Control Systems for precise multi-axis material handling).
Dedicated Non-PLC Controls: These systems shine when the priority is unwavering reliability for specific functions, simplicity, and often, cost-effectiveness:
Straightforward, Dedicated Tasks: For clear-cut operations like basic motor starting/stopping (Standard Motor Controllers), forward/reverse operations (Reversing Motor Controllers), or defined safety sequences.
Critical Safety Functions: Where deterministic, hardwired logic is preferred for its inherent reliability and lack of software-related variables (e.g., our UL Listed Shutdown Panels).
Ease of Maintenance & Troubleshooting: Simpler systems like our Non-PLC Pump Station Controls or Custom Navigation Light Panels can often be maintained by plant electricians without specialized programming knowledge.
Cost Efficiency for Specific Needs: When only a particular function (like soft starting a motor with our Soft Starting Motor Controllers) is required, a dedicated controller is typically more economical than a full PLC.
Fail-Safe Electric: Guiding You to the Optimal Solution
Our process begins with understanding your unique challenge, operational goals, budget, and the capabilities of your team. We then draw upon our comprehensive expertise:
If your application involves complex, interconnected processes, requires extensive data management, or needs the flexibility for future modifications, we'll design a robust PLC-based automation system.
If your focus is on a critical, dedicated function, utmost reliability for a safety interlock, ease of maintenance for straightforward tasks, or a highly cost-effective solution for a specific need, we'll engineer a dependable non-PLC control panel.
Many of our solutions, like VFD Motor Controllers or Supplemental Protection Panels, can be standalone non-PLC units or integrated into larger PLC systems, further showcasing our adaptive approach.
The Benefit of Balanced Expertise: A Solution That Truly Fits
By offering expertise in both PLC and non-PLC technologies, Fail-Safe Electric ensures you receive a control system that is neither over-engineered nor under-powered. You get a solution that is perfectly matched to your requirements, leading to optimal performance, enhanced reliability, better long-term value, and genuine peace of mind. This balanced approach is a hallmark of our Tacoma-based engineering and manufacturing.
Partner with Fail-Safe Electric for Intelligent Control, Intelligently Applied.
Don't settle for a one-technology-fits-all approach. Let the experienced team at Fail-Safe Electric guide you to the control strategy that makes the most sense for your operation.
Contact us today to discuss your project, and we'll help you determine the right control for your job! Call us at 0253-503-3777, email MAINOFFICE@FAIL-SAFEELECTRIC.COM, or visit us at FAIL-SAFEELECTRIC.COM.
Comments